Squashed replay of the original 9-commit branch onto current main. The original branch was 30+ commits behind, forked from before the skills refactor (PR #42) and workflow template expansion (PR #36), so a standard rebase hit heavy add/add conflicts on workflows/*.toml that are unrelated to the wiki hand. This replay keeps only the final hands/wiki/ tree state, which is the actual intent of the PR (the author iterated several times on the same files; squashing matches that). Implements the "LLM Wiki" pattern (Andrej Karpathy) for building a personal, Obsidian-compatible knowledge base. Instead of on-the-fly RAG, the wiki hand incrementally maintains a Markdown vault: hands/wiki/ ├── HAND.toml # hand manifest + [agents.*] sections ├── README.md # user-facing docs ├── SKILL-main.md # Librarian (coordinator) routing + FS ops ├── SKILL-ingestor.md # Source extraction + [[wikilink]] writing ├── SKILL-analyst.md # Synthesis with provenance citations └── SKILL-linter.md # Broken link / orphan / contradiction audit Closes librefang/librefang-registry#44 (via replay, not merge).
7.8 KiB
7.8 KiB
name, version, description, author, tags, runtime
| name | version | description | author | tags | runtime | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| wiki-librarian | 1.0.0 | Wiki Librarian skills — schema management, indexing, linting resolution, and overall vault health. | Leszek3737 |
|
prompt_only |
Wiki Hand — SKILL-main.md
1. Obsidian Conventions
Wikilinks
- Internal cross-references:
[[page-name]](no path, no extension) - Display text override:
[[page-name|Display Text]] - Never use markdown
[text](path)for internal links - External URLs: standard markdown
[text](https://...) - Image embeds:
![[filename.png]] - Images live in
raw/assets/
File Naming
- Format:
kebab-case.md - Max 40 characters (excluding
.md) - ASCII only — transliterate non-ASCII characters (ü → ue, ñ → n, ś → s, etc.)
- Entities: canonical name (
john-doe.md, notdr-john-doe-phd.md) - Concepts: noun phrase (
knowledge-base.md, notabout-knowledge-bases.md) - Sources: derived from title (
the-future-of-ai.md) - Syntheses: derived from query (
tradeoffs-x-vs-y.md) - No version suffixes (_v2, _revised, _updated)
Frontmatter
- Valid YAML between
---delimiters at the top of every page - All fields lowercase with underscores
- Dates: ISO 8601 (
YYYY-MM-DD) - Lists: YAML sequences (not comma-separated strings)
- Dataview-compatible: all fields are queryable
Dataview Compatibility
Useful queries the user can run in Obsidian:
TABLE confidence, source_count, last_updated
FROM "pages/entities"
SORT source_count DESC
LIST
FROM "pages/concepts"
WHERE confidence = "disputed"
TABLE claim_count, date_ingested
FROM "pages/sources"
SORT date_ingested DESC
3. Index and Log Formats
index.md Structure
# Wiki Index
## 5. Cross-Referencing Patterns
### When to Create a Dedicated Page
| Condition | Action |
|-----------|--------|
| Entity/concept is the main subject of a source | Create page |
| Entity/concept appears substantively in 3+ sources | Create page |
| Entity is the author and contributes beyond a byline | Create page |
| Passing mention in < 3 sources, not the main subject | Plain text only, NO page, NO wikilink |
| Librarian or user explicitly requests a page | Create regardless of threshold |
"Substantively" means discussed in at least one paragraph, not just name-dropped.
### Wikilink Rules
- ONLY link to pages that exist. Never create a [[wikilink]] to a non-existent page.
- When creating a new page during ingest, you may wikilink to it from other pages you're touching in the same operation.
- First mention per section: use wikilink `[[page-name]]`
- Subsequent mentions in the same section: plain text is fine
- On creating a new page: check if other existing pages mention this entity/concept in plain text and could now be wikilinked. Flag this in the manifest for Librarian to handle.
### Backlink Maintenance
- On page creation: add the new page to relevant existing pages' "See Also" sections
- On page deletion: replace all inbound [[wikilinks]] with plain text
- On merge: redirect all inbound [[wikilinks]] from deleted page to surviving page
---
## 9. Schema Evolution Patterns
### How to Propose Changes
When Librarian identifies a recurring pattern:
1. State the observation: "I've noticed several entities are research papers. Currently we classify these as tools."
2. Propose a minimal change: "Add `entity_kind: paper` to the entity page schema."
3. Show the before/after diff
4. Wait for user confirmation
5. Optionally suggest a lint pass to retroactively update existing pages
### Backward Compatibility
- New optional fields: add with a default value. Existing pages remain valid.
- New required fields: add as optional first, run lint to find pages missing the field, then promote to required.
- New page types: add template to schema.md, create directory if needed.
- Changed field names: rename in all pages, update schema, lint to verify.
### Common Schema Additions
| Change | When | Example |
|--------|------|---------|
| New `entity_kind` | 3+ entities don't fit existing kinds | `paper`, `event`, `dataset` |
| New tag namespace | Domain-specific taxonomy emerging | `ai/`, `bio/`, `finance/` |
| New frontmatter field | Recurring metadata across pages | `relevance_score`, `review_status` |
| New page type | Distinct content pattern | `timeline`, `glossary`, `comparison` |
---
## 10. Configuration & Settings Reference
The Wiki Hand behavior is governed by settings in `HAND.toml`. The agents should adjust their operations based on these configurations:
### `vault_path`
- **What it is:** The root directory for the Obsidian-compatible wiki.
- **Agent Behavior:** All `shell_exec`, `file_read`, `file_write`, and `file_list` operations must be relative to or prefixed with this path.
- **Best Practice:** Never assume the vault is in the current working directory. Always use the parameterized `{vault_path}`.
### `file_back_mode`
- **What it is:** Determines whether new syntheses generated during user queries are saved back to the wiki.
- **Agent Behavior:**
- `auto`: Automatically save to `pages/syntheses/`, update index, log, and commit.
- `ask`: Ask the user for permission before saving.
- `never`: Only provide the answer in chat. Do not persist the synthesis page.
### `search_backend`
- **What it is:** Specifies the mechanism for querying the wiki.
- **Agent Behavior:**
- `index`: Read `index.md` and visually scan entries. Best for smaller wikis (<200 pages).
- `qmd`: Use the `qmd search` CLI command. Required for larger wikis to avoid context limits.
- **Best Practice:** Proactively suggest switching to `qmd` when the wiki grows beyond 150-200 pages.
### `language`
- **What it is:** The configured language for the wiki content.
- **Agent Behavior:** All generated content, summaries, page titles, and synthesis responses must match this language, even if the user queries in another language or provides foreign-language source materials.
---
## 11. Common Pitfalls & Best Practices
### Tag Proliferation
- **Pitfall:** Creating dozens of highly specific, single-use tags (e.g., `#startup-founded-in-2023`).
- **Best Practice:** Stick to broad, thematic tags (e.g., `#startup`, `#technology`). If more specificity is needed, use `entity_kind` or create a synthesis page grouping them.
### Premature Page Creation (Stubs)
- **Pitfall:** Creating a dedicated entity page for something mentioned only once in passing.
- **Best Practice:** Wait until an entity has 2+ sources or significant context before promoting it to a dedicated page. Otherwise, leave it as a plain-text mention or a generic wikilink in the source summary.
### Broken YAML Frontmatter
- **Pitfall:** Generating invalid YAML (e.g., unescaped quotes in titles, incorrect list formatting for aliases).
- **Best Practice:** Always validate frontmatter syntax mentally before writing. Use arrays correctly: `aliases: ["Name 1", "Name 2"]` or list format. Quote string values if they contain colons.
### Losing Provenance
- **Pitfall:** Extracting a bold claim into an entity page without adding the inline `[[Source]]` tag.
- **Best Practice:** Every key claim or fact MUST have an inline source reference. Information without provenance decays the reliability of the entire wiki.
### Unnecessary Duplication
- **Pitfall:** Creating `Acme Corp.md` when `Acme Corporation.md` already exists, resulting in fragmented knowledge.
- **Best Practice:** Always use cross-category search or `grep` before creating new entity pages. Merge duplicate entries during routine linting.
---
## 2. Page Templates
### 2.1 Source Summary
```markdown
---
type: source
title: "{Original Title}"
author: "{Author Name}"
date_published: YYYY-MM-DD
date_ingested: YYYY-MM-DD
raw_path: "raw/{filename.ext}"
source_url: "{url or null}"
format: md
claim_count: 0
confidence: medium
tags:
- {tag}
---
# {Title}
{2-3 sentence summary in the configured language.}
## 12. Worked Examples